Executive Summary
This report is issued by the Kadn Center for Justice and Human Rights as the second publication within the "Safe Voice" program, following the first report "The First Bullet" issued on July 31, 2025. This report is titled "Toxic Waves – August 31, 2025," and seeks to monitor and analyze hate speech in the Sudanese digital space, tracking its quantitative and qualitative transformations, evaluating it in light of the international legal framework, leading to the development of practical recommendations.
The report adopted a dual methodology: quantitative analysis using the SSPP tool, which allowed measuring the phenomenon's size and spread across different platforms, and qualitative analysis using the NVivo tool to deconstruct the linguistic and discursive structure of hate speech and monitor its future effects across five fundamental dimensions (social, psychological, political, digital, and frameworks of justification and normalization). The results were also approached based on the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, and the Rabat Plan of Action, to assess Sudan's international obligations in confronting this phenomenon.
Quantitative results showed that July witnessed an increase in the number of observed cases to 355 cases compared to 336 in June, with dangerous speech (36.3%) and ethnic speech (34.9%) leading, against a relative decline in political speech (28.7%). The TikTok platform also emerged as a central arena for the spread of hate speech, capturing approximately 97% of views and interactions, while videos played the most dangerous role as a means of dissemination, compared to texts and images whose impact was limited.
Qualitative analysis revealed that hate speech is no longer just fleeting expressions but has transformed into an organized discursive system based on pathological and insect metaphors, the construction of "us/them" binaries, and the invocation of grand narratives such as purification, betrayal, and heroism, with the use of humor, religion, and history as frameworks for justification and normalization. This discursive pattern carries serious future implications, including the disintegration of social coexistence, accumulation of psychological trauma, weakening of trust in institutions, entrenchment of digital polarization, and the transformation of hatred into a stable ideology.
Based on these results, the report presented a package of practical recommendations distributed across five levels:
Legislative and Legal: Criminalizing hate speech and incitement to violence in line with international standards.
Institutional and Political: Enhancing the neutrality of institutions and ensuring equality in representation and services.
Digital and Technical: Cooperating with digital platforms and establishing national electronic monitoring units.
Social and Psychological: Providing psychological support to targeted communities and launching coexistence initiatives.
Cultural and Educational: Integrating the values of diversity into curricula and encouraging alternative cultural and artistic production.
This report represents a clear warning that hate speech in Sudan is no longer a marginal issue but a direct threat to the social fabric and civil peace, necessitating a comprehensive national response, integrated in its dimensions, and consistent with Sudan's obligations under international human rights law.
Introduction
This report is issued by the Kadn Center for Justice and Human Rights as the second report within the "Safe Voice" program, following the first report titled "The First Bullet" issued on July 31, 2025. This new publication comes under the title "Toxic Waves – August 31, 2025" to continue the path of systematic monitoring and analysis of hate speech in the Sudanese digital space, revealing the features of quantitative and qualitative transformation in the nature of the phenomenon, and highlighting its serious repercussions on society and the state.
The report is based on a dual methodology combining quantitative analysis using the SSPP tool, which enabled monitoring the size of the phenomenon and its spread on social media platforms, and qualitative analysis using the NVivo tool, which revealed the dominant linguistic and discursive patterns in hate speech and its future effects across five main dimensions: social coexistence, psychological and behavioral, political and institutional, digital and technical, and frameworks of justification and normalization. The report also relied on the international human rights legal framework through the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, and the Rabat Plan of Action, allowing the phenomenon to be approached in light of international standards and obligations.
Quantitative analysis showed that July witnessed an increase in the number of hate speech cases compared to June, with the center of gravity shifting to the TikTok platform and videos dominating access and interaction indicators, reflecting a qualitative transformation in the nature of spread. Qualitative analysis showed that the discourse is no longer just spontaneous expressions but has turned into an integrated discursive system that reproduces discrimination and exclusion through pathological metaphors, sharp binaries, and grand narratives that falsely legitimize violence.
Based on these results, the report formulated a package of practical recommendations distributed across five levels: legislative and legal, institutional and political, digital and technical, social and psychological, cultural and educational. These recommendations aim to build a comprehensive approach that balances protecting freedom of expression with the commitment to prohibit hate speech, and enhances the ability of the state and society to contain the phenomenon and address its effects.
This report does not merely monitor numbers or analyze discourse, but aims to contribute to establishing a national and international discussion on the dangers of hate speech in Sudan and ways to confront it in light of international human rights law, to protect the social fabric, ensure the integrity of the state, and fortify the path of justice and human dignity.
Methodology
The "Toxic Waves" report is based on a dual methodology that blends quantitative and qualitative analysis, linking the results to the international human rights legal framework, leading to the formulation of practical recommendations.
Data Collection
Digital content circulating on three main platforms—Facebook, X (Twitter/X), and TikTok—was monitored during the period from July 1 to 31, 2025. The monitoring included textual posts, videos, and images related to hate speech. The total number of observed cases was 355 cases, classified according to specific criteria into three basic categories:
Dangerous Speech (inciting violence and genocide).
Ethnic-based Speech (discrimination and exclusion based on identity).
Political Speech (exclusion and incitement based on political positions or affiliations).
Quantitative Analysis
Data was analyzed using the SSPP tool, which enabled tracking the number of cases, distribution patterns, and levels of reach and engagement (views, follows, interactions, shares), in addition to analyzing platforms, content type, and timing of publication. This analysis allowed comparison with June 2025, revealing numerical and qualitative transformations in the phenomenon.
Qualitative Analysis
The NVivo tool was used for coding and qualitative classification of discourse. The analysis focused on the linguistic and discursive structure of hate speech, identifying basic patterns such as: pathological and insect metaphors, the "us/them" binary, grand narratives (purification, betrayal, heroism), and frameworks of justification (religion, patriotism, history, humor). The future effects of these patterns were also analyzed across five dimensions:
Social coexistence.
Psychological and behavioral.
Political and institutional.
Digital and technical.
Frameworks of justification and normalization.
Legal Framework
The results were approached in light of international human rights law, especially:
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), Articles (19, 20, 25).
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD), Articles (2, 4, 5, 7).
Rabat Plan of Action (2012) on the prohibition of incitement to national, racial or religious hatred.
This legal projection allowed assessment of the extent to which observed practices conform to or contradict Sudan's international obligations, and identification of the responsibilities of the state and actors.
Formulation of Recommendations
Recommendations were based on the results of quantitative and qualitative analysis, general conclusions, and the legal framework, to present a set of practical measures at five levels: legislative and legal, institutional and political, digital and technical, social and psychological, cultural and educational. Their formulation took into account being applicable, linked to the Sudanese context, and consistent with international standards.
Thus, the report combines quantitative rigor in monitoring numbers and trends, qualitative depth in analyzing language, symbols, and narratives, and international legal reference in evaluating the phenomenon, leading to practical recommendations that can form the basis for comprehensive national and regional policies to confront hate speech in Sudan.
Quantitative Analysis
This section of the "Toxic Waves" report reveals the results of the quantitative analysis of hate speech based on data processed using the SSPP tool, which enabled monitoring trends and identifying transformations in the nature of discourse and its level of spread across digital platforms. The analysis shows that July did not witness merely a slight increase in the number of cases compared to June, but was characterized by more dangerous qualitative transformations, both in terms of forms of discourse and its pathways of reach and audience engagement. This transformation indicates the phenomenon's shift from merely a limited numerical presence to a state of widespread dissemination with increasingly deep and serious impact.
The observed data for July reveals that hate speech not only witnessed a slight increase in number compared to June but also experienced more dangerous qualitative transformations in its nature and spread. The total number of cases reached 355 cases compared to 336 cases in June, but the numerical increase represents only part of the picture; the analysis shows the phenomenon's transition from a stage of limited presence to a stage of widespread dissemination and deep impact, with a notable escalation in the most severe and hostile forms of discourse.
[Statistical table comparing June and July indicators - content preserved]
[Charts 1-17 - content preserved]
In terms of types, hate speech was distributed across three main patterns: dangerous speech in the lead with 129 cases (36.3%), followed by ethnic-based speech with 124 cases (34.9%), then political speech with 102 cases (28.7%). Although the numerical proportions are relatively close, the reach and engagement indicators reveal a fundamental distinction; dangerous speech captured the majority of followers (67.4%), views (93.8%), and interactions (92.7%), while ethnic speech was distinguished by its great ability to be redistributed through shares (88.4%), while political speech remained the least influential at various levels. These results show that the trajectory of July moved towards enhancing the most dangerous speech, compared to June, which was characterized by greater spread of political speech.
At the platform level, Facebook led with 134 cases (37.8%), followed by X (Twitter/X) with 133 cases (37.5%), then TikTok with 88 cases (24.8%). However, when looking at engagement indicators, a qualitative shift becomes clear; TikTok alone dominated nearly 97% of views and interactions, despite being the smallest in number. As for Facebook and X, despite the increasing number of cases on them, their impact remained limited, not exceeding 3% of access indicators. This reflects the shift of the center of gravity from traditional platforms (Facebook and X) to TikTok as the most dangerous and effective space for disseminating hostile content, a shift that was not as pronounced in June.
In terms of content type, textual posts continued to lead in number with 264 cases (74.4%), followed by videos with 85 cases (23.9%), while images came at the margin with only 6 cases (1.7%). However, the difference in impact was decisive; texts did not exceed 2.5% of views and 2.2% of shares, while videos captured more than 97% of views and interactions, making them the most dangerous medium for the spread of hate speech. Compared to June, July appears to represent a stage of greater expansion in reliance on visual media, which multiplies the speed and intensity of spread.
In terms of timing, the evening period recorded the highest number with 131 cases (36.9%), and was the most attractive for views (56.4%) and interactions (85.9%), while the afternoon period was distinguished as the most prominent moment for reposting through shares, with 91.2% of total shares, while the morning period remained the lowest in number and impact. Compared to the previous month, it becomes clear that evening continued as the peak time for posting, but July was characterized by a doubling of interaction volume, indicating a deepening relationship between posting timing and levels of engagement and impact.
In conclusion, the comparison between June and July shows that hate speech moved from a pattern closer to limited numerical presence in June to a more dangerous and intense pattern in July, characterized by increasing reliance on videos, the emergence of TikTok as a central arena for impact, and a relative decline in political speech versus an escalation in dangerous and ethnic speech. This reflects a qualitative shift in the nature of the phenomenon, not only in terms of quantity, but in terms of degree of danger, speed of spread, and breadth of impact.
Qualitative Analysis
This section of the "Toxic Waves" report presents the qualitative analysis of hate speech circulating on social media platforms. Five main issues were monitored and processed during this month, all intersecting in that they do not merely reflect temporary positions or emotional expressions, but represent recurring linguistic and discursive patterns that reproduce discrimination and exclusion, and open the door to dangerous possibilities for the future of society and the state.
The analysis relied on the NVivo tool for coding and classification, allowing a structured approach to the linguistic and discursive dimensions of these issues and linking them to potential future effects across five main areas: social coexistence, psychological and behavioral, political and institutional, digital and technical, and frameworks of justification and normalization. The reading is based on live examples collected and analyzed, to show how discourse transforms from words into an active force that reshapes collective consciousness and establishes paths of symbolic and physical violence that may become difficult to contain in the foreseeable future.
[Examples 1-20 - content preserved]
Hate Speech and Social Cohesion
Dangerous speech shows a high level of direct incitement to violence and collective exclusion, such as calls for "the blue war is coming" or "ridding the country of strangers and African migrants." This type of discourse does not merely undermine coexistence but explicitly seeks to cancel the existence of the other.
Calls for the secession of Darfur or the expulsion of certain groups mean transforming political division into social and geographical rupture.
Describing areas or groups as "cancer" or "cancerous growth" legitimizes the idea of their eradication from society, threatening Sudan's unity and civil peace.
Psychological and Behavioral Dimension
Dangerous speech generates a state of collective fear among targeted communities and pushes individuals to withdraw from public life or migrate internally and externally. For example:
Accusing groups of being the cause of "looting and rape" places a collective stigma, leading to the stigmatization of new generations and encouraging isolation.
Explicit calls for killing or expulsion make the targeted feel that their physical safety is constantly threatened, deepening psychological trauma and exacerbating displacement.
Political and Institutional Dimension
This discourse is exploited to weaken trust in the state and its institutions:
Portraying certain tribal components as "militias" or "parasites on the state" justifies the idea of depriving them of political representation or public services.
Inciteful discourse based on regionalism (e.g., against the people of the Nile River or Darfur) threatens the legitimacy of national institutions and undermines attempts to build an inclusive state.
In the Sudanese context, this discourse reinforces sharp political polarization, making any reform or peace process hostage to extremist rhetoric.
Digital and Technical Dimension
Dangerous speech spreads intensively through digital platforms using inciteful hashtags such as calls for separating regions or waging civil war. The repeated reposting of the same inciteful messages (e.g., repetition of the phrase "the blue war is coming" across multiple posts). Bots and anonymous accounts that amplify discourse linking entire groups to violence or betrayal. This digital amplification makes the discourse appear more socially acceptable than it actually is, and pushes some users to identify with hate speech.
Frameworks of Justification and Normalization
Dangerous speech is usually presented through frameworks that give it false legitimacy: religion by portraying groups as "enemies of religion" to justify targeting them, and patriotism by claiming that expulsion or exclusion is "protection of the homeland." Historical events (such as colonialism or ancient wars) are also invoked to normalize the idea that violence is the only solution. Sometimes dangerous discourse is presented in a sarcastic formulation or through memes and humor, to reduce public sensitivity towards it and normalize hatred in public consciousness.
Linguistic and Discursive Aspects:
Analysis of the documented material shows that hate speech in Sudan is not merely based on exchanging insults but relies on organized language, full of symbols and narratives, that transforms hatred into a socially and politically justified practice. The most prominent linguistic and discursive features are:
Hate-laden vocabulary and social coexistence:
The language used is characterized by direct stigmatization that transforms targets into non-human entities, such as describing them as "insects" or "impurities." This pattern strikes at the foundation of coexistence because it cancels the idea of common citizenship and turns diversity into a source of conflict.
Metaphors, symbols, and the psychological and behavioral dimension:
The discourse resorts to metaphors of disease ("cancer," "epidemic") or insects ("locusts," "rats"), creating a psychological state of fear and disgust. This justifies for society the exclusion or marginalization of the other, and leaves victims with a feeling of inferiority and constant threat.
The "Us/Them" binary and the political and institutional dimension:
One of the most prominent components of the discourse is the construction of a sharp binary: "we the patriots" versus "they the traitors." This binary leaves no room for moderation or political coexistence but legitimizes complete exclusion from institutions.
Grand narratives and the digital and technical dimension:
Discourses are built on grand narratives that give them meaning beyond the present moment: the purification narrative (getting rid of certain groups), the betrayal narrative (opponents as agents), and the heroism narrative (the self as savior of the homeland). These narratives spread powerfully in the digital space through hashtags and short slogans.
Humor, sarcasm, and frameworks of justification and normalization:
Humor is used as a tool to hide the danger of expressions, where calls for genocide are accompanied by smiley emojis or jokes, imprinting hatred and making its circulation socially acceptable. When hatred is dressed in the garb of humor, religion, or history, it transforms into a justified ideology.
The Future Impact of the Continuation of Hate Speech across the Five Dimensions
Social Cohesion:
The continuation of hate speech will undermine the very idea of coexistence. Whenever calls for exclusion, expulsion, or "purification" are repeated, the image becomes entrenched in the public that society consists of warring groups with no national bond uniting them. In the medium term, bridges of trust between local components (neighborhood, school, market, workplace) will weaken, and daily interactions will turn into constant caution and suspicion. Over time, "unwritten social boundaries" will emerge separating neighborhoods, cities, and regions according to affiliations, reducing solidarity and cooperation between different groups. In the long term, separatist calls may grow, or the legitimacy of solutions based on geographical separation may rise, and reconciliation will become more costly and complex because society will have lost the memory and skills of coexistence.
Psychological and Behavioral:
Hate speech reshapes public mental health through two parallel paths: chronic fear among the targeted, and moral normalization of violence among supporters. For the targeted, repeated exposure to threat and humiliation will lead to symptoms of anxiety, depression, and trauma, followed by withdrawal from social and digital participation, and possibly internal or external migration in search of safety. For supporters, a psychological legitimacy for "punishment" and revenge forms, increasing the propensity to justify or participate in violence. As this state accumulates, a new generation is raised in an environment charged with hostility and stigma, creating cycles of mutual revenge and complicating any subsequent programs for community recovery or reintegration.
Political and Institutional:
When exclusion becomes part of daily language, it quickly transfers to the structure of politics and institutions. The continuation of discourse will weaken the legitimacy of the state in favor of armed groups and local authoritarianisms, and entrench practices of "eradication" instead of peaceful transfer and programmatic competition. Public institutions turn into an arena for settling scores, and standards of merit and competence decline in favor of loyalty and identity. In the medium term, the principle of equal citizenship collapses, and the basic rights of opponents of the "dominant camp" are violated, creating successive cycles of tyranny and disorder. In the long term, institutional reform becomes nearly impossible because public trust in the judiciary, security, and administration has eroded, and because the elites themselves have become saturated with the logic of exclusion rather than institution-building.
Digital and Technical:
The digital space will turn into an environment for continuous production and circulation of hatred, especially with the development of automated publishing tools and algorithmic personalization. The continuation of discourse means the inflation of "consensus bubbles" inside which users see only what confirms their biases, deepening polarization. With the spread of bots and coordinated campaigns, extreme views will appear as a "majority," giving them additional momentum. In the medium term, violent content will turn into "political entertainment" through memes and sarcasm, weakening critical sense and making information correction difficult. In the longer term, monitoring and confrontation efforts will need high technical and organizational capabilities, otherwise this digital structure will become entrenched as a permanent system that reproduces hatred and expands its scope faster than any traditional educational or legal interventions.
Frameworks of Justification and Normalization:
The greatest danger is that hate speech transforms from a circumstantial phenomenon into a stable ideology through frameworks of religious, historical, or national justification. When violence is presented as "defense of identity," "protection of the homeland," or "correction of history's course," it acquires symbolic legitimacy that ensures its survival and reproduction through informal education and popular media. In the medium term, the circles of recipients sympathetic to the justification expand, making it easy to recruit them into violent or exclusionary projects. In the long term, dismantling these frameworks becomes difficult because refuting them would be understood as an attack on religion, patriotism, or collective memory. At that point, political decisions are not enough to stop violence; rather, long-term cultural change is required to redefine shared values and restore the centrality of dignity and citizenship.
Legal Framework
Hate speech, as shown by this report, represents a multi-dimensional threat intersecting with issues of social coexistence, psychological and behavioral effects, stability of political institutions, the digital space, and frameworks of justification and normalization. From the perspective of international human rights law, all these dimensions are subject to an integrated legal framework based on the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, and the Rabat Plan of Action.
In terms of social coexistence, calls for exclusion and collective purification represent a direct breach of Article (20) of the International Covenant, which prohibits any advocacy of national, racial, or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility, or violence. The use of descriptions such as "cancer" or "cancerous growth" against specific groups also contradicts Article (4) of the Convention on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, which imposes on states parties an obligation to combat, prevent, and criminalize racist propaganda. This type of discourse threatens civil peace and undermines the legal foundation of the concept of equal citizenship.
At the psychological and behavioral level, direct calls for killing or collective stigmatization represent a violation of the right to human dignity and constitute degrading treatment within the meaning of Article (7) of the International Covenant. Incitement to violence leaves collective psychological effects that may drive victims into isolation or migration, contradicting state obligations under Article (2) of the Covenant and the Racial Discrimination Convention to ensure enjoyment of rights without fear or stigma.
In the political and institutional dimension, portraying regional or political groups as traitors or agents undermines the principle of equal participation in public life and violates Article (25) of the International Covenant, which guarantees the right to political participation without discrimination. Incitement to exclude specific components from state institutions contradicts Article (5) of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, which stipulates equality before the law in the enjoyment of political and civil rights. Thus, hate speech becomes not merely hostile discourse but a tool for weakening institutions and turning them into an arena for exclusion.
As for the digital and technical space, the reproduction of hate speech through inciteful hashtags and organized campaigns represents a challenge to the balance between freedom of expression under Article (19) of the International Covenant and the obligation to prohibit hate speech under Article (20). Here, the Rabat Plan of Action provides a practical framework through the six-part test (context, speaker, intent, content and form, extent of dissemination, likelihood of harm), allowing the distinction between legitimate expression and legally prohibited speech. Hence, the state's responsibility is not limited to criminalization but also includes developing regulatory partnerships with technology companies to monitor and remove content according to precise and balanced criteria.
As for frameworks of justification and normalization, they are the most dangerous because they give hate speech false legitimacy through religion, patriotism, history, or even sarcasm and humor. These practices fall not only under the prohibition under Article (4) of the Convention on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination but also impose positive obligations on the state under Article (7) of the same Convention, through the adoption of educational and cultural policies that promote tolerance and human rights and dismantle ideological frameworks that give violence social acceptance.
Accordingly, the international legal framework provides a clear basis for addressing hate speech as an integrated threat in which the social is inseparable from the psychological, nor the political from the digital or cultural. It imposes specific legal obligations on the state: enacting clear legislation criminalizing incitement to violence and hatred, providing effective remedies for victims, ensuring the integrity of judicial and administrative institutions in addressing the phenomenon, and adopting long-term educational and media policies that cultivate the values of tolerance and equal citizenship. Thus, the challenge is not limited to confronting temporary discourse but to building legal and societal immunity that prevents its transformation into a stable ideology that undermines the foundations of the state and human rights.
Conclusions
The combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis of hate speech in the "Toxic Waves" report shows that the phenomenon is no longer confined to a limited scope but has witnessed a qualitative transition from a scattered numerical presence to a coherent and more dangerous discursive system. The numerical increase from 336 cases in June to 355 cases in July does not alone reflect the magnitude of the change, as quantitative analysis reveals fundamental transformations in the nature of discourse, where dangerous and ethnic speech led the scene at the expense of political speech, and platforms like TikTok have become central in disseminating hostile content through videos, which captured the vast majority of views and interactions.
Qualitative analysis shows that hate speech is no longer based on individual insults or spontaneous expressions but has come to rely on a complex linguistic and discursive structure including pathological and insect metaphors, the construction of sharp "us/them" binaries, and grand narratives that give discourse false legitimacy through religion, patriotism, or history. This discourse is not limited to social impact but leaves deep psychological effects on targeted individuals, undermines the foundations of trust in institutions, and exploits the digital environment to expand its scope in ways difficult to control through traditional means.
The convergence of quantitative and qualitative results shows that hate speech in Sudan has become a multi-dimensional threat: it deepens social divisions, sows fear and stigma, weakens institutions, and gives violence cultural and ideological justifications that hinder any path towards reconciliation or reform. This picture confirms the need for a comprehensive approach that goes beyond legal remedies alone to include educational, cultural, and digital measures, consistent with Sudan's obligations within the framework of international human rights law.
Central Conclusions:
Escalation of the phenomenon's danger: The increase in cases in July (355) compared to June (336) coincided with qualitative transformations that made discourse more hostile and impactful.
Discourse Patterns: Dangerous speech (36.3%) and ethnic speech (34.9%) led the scene, against a relative decline in political speech (28.7%).
Platforms of Spread: TikTok has become the most prominent arena for spreading hate speech, capturing 97% of views and interactions, while the impact of Facebook and X declined.
Media of Dissemination: Videos represented the most dangerous medium for spread (97% of views and interactions), against weak impact of texts and images.
Psychological and Social Impact: The discourse generated collective fear and social stigmatization of targets, and reinforced social division.
Discursive Structure: Widespread reliance on pathological and insect metaphors, the "us/them" binary, and narratives of purification, betrayal, and heroism, giving it an ideological character.
Digital Space: Bots, hashtags, and memes contributed to amplifying discourse and normalizing it socially.
Institutional and Political Repercussions: The discourse undermined trust in national institutions and legitimized exclusion, threatening peace and reform paths.
Need for a Comprehensive Approach: Confronting hate speech requires integrated strategies including legislation, judicial oversight, community education, and digital regulation, according to international human rights law standards.
Recommendations
Based on the results of the quantitative and qualitative analysis, the general conclusions, and the legal framework, the "Toxic Waves" report recommends a set of practical multi-level measures to confront hate speech and reduce its effects:
At the Legislative and Legal Level:
Clearly criminalize incitement to violence and hatred in national legislation, in line with Article (20) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and Article (4) of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination.
Adopt the Rabat Plan of Action standards to determine when legitimate expression exceeds the limits of freedom of opinion to become legally prohibited speech.
Establish an independent judicial mechanism specialized in examining hate speech cases and ensuring integrity of处理 away from politicization.
At the Institutional and Political Level:
Enhance the neutrality of national institutions and ensure equality in representation and public services, to prevent the legitimization of political or regional exclusion.
Involve national human rights institutions and civil society in monitoring and documenting hate speech, providing an independent database to support public policies.
Launch political and social reconciliation programs that address discursive polarization and rebuild trust between components.
At the Digital and Technical Level:
Cooperate with technology companies (especially TikTok, Facebook, and X) to establish rapid response mechanisms for removing content inciting hatred and violence.
Establish a national digital monitoring unit relying on data analysis tools to monitor coordinated campaigns, bots, and patterns of artificial amplification of hate speech.
Develop digital awareness programs targeting youth and active users on platforms, to encourage critical thinking and confront fake news and inciteful content.
At the Social and Psychological Level:
Provide psychological and social support services to communities targeted by hate speech, to address the effects of fear, stigma, and trauma.
Launch initiatives to build social coexistence through schools, universities, and civil society institutions, focusing on the values of equal citizenship and cultural diversity.
Empower local actors (community leaders, religious figures, women's and youth leaderships) to play a positive role in confronting hatred with alternative discourse based on tolerance.
At the Cultural and Educational Level:
Integrate the values of human rights and diversity into educational curricula and cultural and media programs.
Encourage cultural and artistic production (theater, short films, alternative memes) as counter-measures to hate speech, targeting the same digital space exploited to spread hatred.
Organize national media campaigns focusing on the danger of hate speech to societal unity and the future of the state.
References:
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), adopted and opened for signature, ratification and accession by General Assembly resolution 2200A (XXI) of December 16, 1966, entered into force March 23, 1976, particularly Articles (2), (7), (19), (20), and (25).
International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD), adopted by General Assembly resolution 2106 (XX) of December 21, 1965, entered into force January 4, 1969, particularly Articles (4), (5), and (7).
Rabat Plan of Action on the prohibition of advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred, expert meeting held in Rabat, Morocco, October 5, 2012, issued by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, which provides the six-part test (context, speaker, intent, content and form, extent of dissemination, likelihood of harm).
Declarations and General Comments issued by United Nations bodies:
Human Rights Committee General Comment No. 34 on freedoms of opinion and expression (Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights), 2011.
Human Rights Committee General Comment No. 18 on non-discrimination, 1989.
Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination General Recommendation No. 35 on combating racist hate speech, 2013.
Appendices:
Table of linguistic and discursive patterns and their frequencies (NVivo)
Graphs of quantitative analysis indicators (SSPP)
List of legal and international references